Ed Gingerich and the Tragic Story of an Amish Family Torn Apart

Ed Gingerich

Who Was Ed Gingerich

Old Order Amish man Edward D. Gingerich, known as Ed Gingerich, had one of the most frightening and terrible stories in the Amish community in the US. Ed was born in Norwich, Ontario, Canada, on August 18, 1963, into an Amish family that practiced religious discipline, agricultural work, humble living, and isolation.

His family moved to a 150-acre farm near Mill Village in Rockdale Township, Crawford County, Pennsylvania, in spring 1983. The family helped found Brownhill Amish village. Ed moved to a new Amish village, but his personal troubles would become entwined with the settlement’s history.

Ed was born to Dannie or Dan and Mary Gingerich. He was raised by Amish parents with eight children. Education ended at eighth grade, and farming, craftsmanship, family, and religion dominated daily life.

Ed struggled to blend into his surroundings. Younger accounts characterize him as gloomy and short-tempered. He also liked machinery and non-Amish people. Ed’s growing conflict between his desires and expectations was represented in these nonviolent inclinations.

Ed Gingerich and Katie Shetler

Katie Gingerich, born Katie Shetler, became the central figure in Ed’s personal life and ultimately the victim of the tragedy that defined his story.

Katie was the daughter of Levi and Emma Shetler and the niece of Bishop Rudy Shetler. Within the Brownhill community, she was remembered as hardworking and energetic, qualities highly valued in traditional Amish family life.

Ed and Katie began dating intermittently around the fall of 1985. Their relationship eventually led to marriage on December 2, 1986. Bishop Rudy Shetler officiated at the wedding, and Katie wore a dark blue dress consistent with Amish wedding traditions.

The couple initially lived in the basement of Katie’s parents’ home. Later, Ed’s father built a modest house for them. Their household gradually expanded as children arrived.

The family appeared outwardly conventional, but Ed’s mental health was deteriorating. After the birth of his first child, his depression reportedly became more severe. He began experiencing hallucinations and increasingly troubling thoughts.

The Gingerich Children

Ed and Katie had three children, all of whom were very young when Katie died in 1993.

Family member Birth information Relationship to Ed
Dannie E. Gingerich September 20, 1987 Eldest son
Enos Gingerich Around March 1989 Second son
Mary Gingerich March 13, 1990 Daughter

Dannie, sometimes called Danny or Daniel, was approximately five or six years old when his mother was killed. During the attack, Katie told him to run for help. The little boy reportedly ran barefoot for roughly half a mile to a mile to reach an uncle’s home.

That desperate run became one of the most haunting details of the case. A child who should have been protected inside his family home instead became the messenger who summoned help.

Enos was approximately four years old at the time. He witnessed portions of the violence, leaving him, like his siblings, to grow up with memories of an event that permanently changed his family.

Mary, born March 13, 1990, was only about three years old. She also witnessed parts of what happened. After Katie’s death, she and her brothers were primarily raised by their grandparents, Daniel and Mary Gingerich.

The children later experienced complicated relationships with their father. Some family members temporarily reconciled with Ed, but those relationships could result in shunning within the Amish community. The children’s connections to Ed therefore became entangled with both personal trauma and community expectations.

Ed’s Work and Amish Life

Before his criminal case, Ed worked in woodworking, carpentry, farming, and mechanical activities. He was particularly interested in machinery and eventually built a machine shop around 1988.

The shop allowed him to repair motors and farm equipment. He also became involved in planning and construction associated with a mill.

His abilities gave him a practical role within the agricultural and craft based environment surrounding him. At the same time, his interest in machinery and interaction with non Amish people placed him somewhat closer to the outside world than some members of his community preferred.

There is little evidence that Ed accumulated significant personal wealth. His life was disrupted by mental illness, hospitalizations, incarceration, and later supervised living arrangements. His story is therefore not one of financial success or professional fame. His legacy rests almost entirely on his family, his illness, the 1993 killing, and the consequences that followed.

Ed’s Mental Health Struggles

The 1993 occurrences are linked to Ed’s mental decline.

Depression, hallucinations, paranoia, and insanity plagued him before the murder. He developed paranoid schizophrenia. He was hospitalized multiple times in 1992, including at Hamot and Jones Memorial.

Ed loathed the side effects of medication, which lessened his symptoms. He said the medication made him feel like a “zombie.” Consequently, he frequently skipped his medication.

Danger increased. Some community members reported his actions to police, while others struggled to handle a profoundly mentally ill guy in a secluded religious group.

Outside religious forces contributed to Ed’s anguish. An acquaintance, Dave Lindsey, advised him to renounce Amish principles or face spiritual consequences. Ed’s illusions concentrated on Katie, whom he supposedly connected with the devil.

Untreated mental illness, religious conflict, family tension, and psychosis formed a lethal storm.

The 1993 Killing of Katie Gingerich

On March 18, 1993, the crisis reached its horrifying peak.

Ed attacked Katie inside the kitchen of their farmhouse in Rockdale Township. Their three children were in or near the house.

According to accounts of the case, Ed punched Katie in the face and knocked her down. Katie called for her oldest son, Dannie, to run for help. The boy obeyed and fled barefoot toward an uncle’s home.

Ed then continued the assault. He put on heavy boots and repeatedly stomped Katie’s head. He subsequently used a kitchen knife to cut open her abdomen and remove internal organs.

The violence was extraordinarily brutal, particularly within a community where such homicide was virtually unknown. Two of the younger children witnessed parts of the attack.

When an uncle reached the farmhouse and saw Ed standing over Katie’s body, he fled to a nearby non Amish home to call for emergency assistance. Authorities soon became involved, and Ed was arrested after being located nearby with the children.

During police questioning, Ed reportedly expressed confusion about what had happened and indicated that he believed Katie might somehow still be saved.

For me, one of the most tragic elements of the story is the contrast between the ordinary setting and the extraordinary violence. This was not a distant crime scene or an isolated wilderness. It was a family kitchen, a place normally associated with food, children, work, and daily Amish life.

The Trial and Prison Sentence

The case went to trial in 1994. Ed was not convicted of first degree murder. Instead, a jury found him guilty of involuntary manslaughter but mentally ill.

He received a sentence of two and a half to five years. He served the full term, including time in a psychiatric prison setting, and was released from SCI Mercer on March 19, 1998.

The legal outcome reflected the central question surrounding the case: how should the justice system respond to a person who committed a horrifying act while suffering from severe mental illness?

Ed’s conviction became historically significant because he was regarded as the first Amish person convicted of homicide in the United States.

Life After Prison

Ed’s release did not restore the family he had lost.

After leaving prison, he spent time in Amish mental health facilities in Michigan and Indiana. He eventually returned to the Brownhill area in February 2007.

His return produced a major division within the community. Some people believed that forgiveness and supervision were possible. Others feared Ed and believed he should remain separated from the community.

The disagreement was especially painful because his children were now older. They had grown up without their mother and largely under the care of their grandparents.

In April 2007, Ed and his brothers Atlee and Joseph became involved in an incident concerning his daughter Mary, who was then 17. She was taken from a buggy while traveling with an aunt and was later found safe in McKean County.

Ed faced charges connected to interference with custody and conspiracy. He eventually pleaded no contest and received six months of probation and a fine, along with restrictions concerning contact.

In 2008, he pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor illegal hunting offense and served approximately three months.

The family’s wounds remained open. Some relatives tried to reconnect with Ed, while others continued to keep their distance.

Ed’s Final Years

By about 2010, Ed had moved into the household of attorney George Schroeck and his wife, Stephanie, in the Cambridge Springs and Rockdale area.

He continued receiving psychiatric care and medication management, but his struggles persisted.

On January 14, 2011, Ed was found dead in a barn on the Schroeck property. Stephanie discovered him after he had gone to feed the horses and failed to return.

He had died by suicide.

A particularly poignant detail was found at the scene. Ed had written a short message in dust on a bucket: “Forgive me please.”

He was 47 years old according to the August 18, 1963 birth date, although some accounts have given a different birth year.

Burial Beside Katie

Ed was buried in the Amish cemetery beside Katie.

The burial decision was controversial because of the circumstances of his death and the Amish understanding of suicide. Nevertheless, some members of Katie’s family supported allowing him to be buried beside his wife.

The image of the two graves together is difficult to separate from the history between them. Katie’s life ended in the farmhouse where she had raised her children, while Ed’s life ended nearly 18 years later in a barn after years of imprisonment, psychiatric treatment, family conflict, and attempts at reconciliation.

Their children were left to carry the memories of both parents.

The Gingerich Family After the Tragedy

Multiple households were affected by the killing. It strained Gingerich family relationships and raised Brownhill settlement issues.

Daniel and Mary, Ed’s parents, raised his kids. Ed’s brothers Atlee and Joseph later became embroiled in family issues, including the 2007 custody dispute.

The children have difficult father-child relationships. Dannie and Enos reconciled with Ed throughout their teens, but the community shunned them. Both left him again.

After the custody dispute, Mary avoided Ed.

The family story became one of separation and reconciliation. Fear, allegiance, religious restrictions, forgiveness, and childhood trauma clashed.

A Timeline of Ed Gingerich’s Life

Date Event
August 18, 1963 Ed Gingerich was born in Norwich, Ontario
Spring 1983 His family moved to Rockdale Township, Pennsylvania
Fall 1985 Ed began dating Katie Shetler
December 2, 1986 Ed and Katie married
September 20, 1987 Son Dannie was born
Around March 1989 Son Enos was born
March 13, 1990 Daughter Mary was born
1992 Ed experienced severe psychiatric episodes and hospitalizations
March 18, 1993 Katie Gingerich was killed
1994 Ed was convicted of involuntary manslaughter but mentally ill
March 19, 1998 Ed was released from prison
February 2007 He returned to the Brownhill area
April 2007 Custody interference incident involving Mary
2008 Ed received a misdemeanor illegal hunting conviction
Around 2010 He moved into the Schroeck household
January 14, 2011 Ed died by suicide
2011 He was buried beside Katie

FAQ

Who was Ed Gingerich?

Ed Gingerich was an Old Order Amish man from the Brownhill settlement in Crawford County, Pennsylvania. He became known nationally after killing his wife Katie in 1993 during a severe psychotic episode associated with paranoid schizophrenia.

Who was Katie Gingerich?

Katie Gingerich, née Shetler, was Ed’s wife and the mother of their three children. She married Ed on December 2, 1986, and was killed by him on March 18, 1993.

How many children did Ed and Katie Gingerich have?

They had three children: Dannie E. Gingerich, born September 20, 1987; Enos Gingerich, born around March 1989; and Mary Gingerich, born March 13, 1990.

What happened to Ed Gingerich after the killing?

Ed was arrested and later convicted of involuntary manslaughter but mentally ill. He was sentenced to two and a half to five years and was released from prison on March 19, 1998. He subsequently spent time in Amish mental health facilities before returning to Pennsylvania in 2007.

What happened to Ed Gingerich in 2007?

After returning to the Brownhill area, Ed became involved in a custody interference incident involving his 17 year old daughter Mary. He pleaded no contest to related charges and received probation, a fine, and restrictions concerning contact.

When did Ed Gingerich die?

Ed Gingerich died on January 14, 2011. He was found hanged in a barn on the property where he was living. His death was ruled a suicide.

Where was Ed Gingerich buried?

Ed was buried in an Amish cemetery beside his wife, Katie. The decision was controversial within the community because of the circumstances surrounding his death, but the burial was ultimately permitted.

Who raised Ed Gingerich’s children?

After Katie’s death, the three children were raised primarily by Ed’s parents, Daniel and Mary Gingerich.

Was Ed Gingerich diagnosed with schizophrenia?

Yes. Ed was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia after experiencing serious psychiatric symptoms, including hallucinations, paranoia, depression, and psychotic episodes. His treatment included psychiatric hospitalization and medication.

Why is the Ed Gingerich case significant?

The case became notable because it was regarded as the first known homicide conviction involving an Old Order Amish person in the United States. It also exposed a painful intersection of severe mental illness, religious isolation, family trauma, criminal justice, and Amish community life.

0 Shares:
You May Also Like